It started with shaving underarms - Part 2

 OTHER PARTS | ALL STORY LIST

The next evening, the final blow came from a different front. His phone buzzed with a FaceTime request. His parents. A weekly ritual he usually endured with a sort of fond detachment.

He accepted, forcing a smile onto his face. “Hey, Mom. Dad.”

His mother’s face filled the screen, her smile warm but edged with its usual anxiety. “Alex, honey! You look pale. Are you eating enough?”

Before he could answer, his father’s face leaned into the frame, his presence solid and unchanging as granite. “He’s fine, Carol. The boy’s fine. Right, son? Crushing it in the big city?”

“Yeah, Dad. Crushing it.”

They talked about the Yankees, about his father’s golf game. The script was familiar. Then his dad, as he always did, steered the conversation to his favorite topic: legacy.

“You remember Joe Matheson’s boy?” his father said, not waiting for an answer. “The one who played linebacker in college? Well, he just made partner at his firm. Thirty-two years old. Now that’s a man who knows how to make his mark.” He chuckled, a low, rumbling sound. “Makes me proud just thinking about it. A real chip off the old block.”

Chip off the old block. The words echoed in the silent, empty space of his apartment. He looked at his father’s face, so sure of the world and his son’s place in it. He thought of the BB cream in his bathroom, the Pilates videos on his phone, the silk blouse in his closet.

A wave of vertigo washed over him. The distance between the man on the screen—the son, the boyfriend, the “macho office worker”—and the person trembling on his couch was an unbridgeable chasm.

He couldn’t do it. He couldn’t sit there and nod while his father praised a version of masculinity that felt like a foreign language.

“I have to go,” he blurted out, his voice tight. “There’s… a work thing. An email I have to send.”

The concern on his mother’s face deepened. “On a Sunday night?”

“It’s New York, Mom. It never stops.” The lie was effortless now.

“Alright, son,” his father said, a hint of approval in his voice. “That’s the hustle. Go get ‘em.”

The call ended. The screen went black.

Alex sat in the sudden, crushing silence. The facade was splintering, and he was cutting everyone he loved on the sharp edges. He was lying to his girlfriend, hiding from his parents, and performing a pantomime for his colleagues.

He stood up and walked to his closet. He didn’t open it. He just stood before the closed door, his forehead resting against the cool wood.

He was trapped in the life of Alex Rossi, and the only person who knew he was drowning was the woman silently waiting on the other side of the door. The unraveling had begun, and there was no going back.

The silence after his parents' call was a physical weight. For two days, he moved through his life like a ghost, the echo of his father’s voice—“a real chip off the old block”—a taunt in his mind. The performance was becoming excruciating. Every "bro" from a colleague, every "man's man" comment from Chloe, felt like a tiny, precise incision.

He stood in front of his closet on Wednesday morning, the usual uniform of chinos and a polo shirt feeling like a prisoner’s jumpsuit. His eyes drifted, as they always did, to the back, where the emerald blouse and grey cardigan hung. A reckless, desperate idea began to form.

He couldn’t wear the blouse. That was a bridge too far, a declaration of war he wasn't ready to make. But what about the cardigan? It was soft, grey, and undeniably neutral. And the jeans… the women’s skinny jeans he’d bought. They were just dark wash denim, right? From a distance, who could tell?

And his face… he’d been perfecting the "no-makeup makeup" in the privacy of his bathroom. It was just tinted moisturizer and a dab of concealer. It wasn't makeup, not really. It was just… enhancement.

This wasn't about becoming her. Not yet. This was about testing the waters. About seeing if a single, fragile thread of his true self could survive in the harsh light of his real world.

His hands trembled as he dressed. The cashmere of the cardigan felt like a secret embrace. The skinny jeans, once so foreign, now felt like a second skin, hugging his legs in a way that was both comforting and terrifyingly revealing. In the bathroom, he applied the products with a surgeon’s precision, blending until his skin was even, his under-eye circles vanished. He looked… refreshed. Polished. Not feminine, but not entirely masculine either. He looked like himself, just a slightly feminal, more curated version.

The walk to the subway was an exercise in paranoia. He felt like a neon sign was flashing above his head: LOOK AT ME. I'M womanly. He kept his head down, his shoulders slightly hunched, trying to diminish his frame. On the train, he avoided eye contact, convinced every glance was a judgment, every whisper was about him.

The office lobby was his first major checkpoint. He swiped his badge, the familiar beep a sound of normalcy in his abnormal world. He walked towards the bank of elevators, his heart thudding against his ribs.

The first person to notice was Kevin from Accounting. Their eyes met for a split second as the elevator doors closed. Kevin’s gaze did a quick, almost imperceptible dip—from Alex’s face, down the line of the cardigan, to the tight fit of the jeans—before flicking back up with a slight, confused frown. He didn't say anything, but the look was a bucket of cold water. Alex felt exposed.

At his desk, he kept his head buried in his monitor, the glow a welcome shield. He felt the occasional glance from a passing colleague. A few double-takes. No one said anything. The office hummed with its usual energy, but to Alex, the air was thick with unspoken questions. It was the humiliation from the boss's jokes all over again, but this time, it was silent, a thousand tiny paper cuts instead of one blunt blow. He regretted everything. This was a mistake.

His coffee run was a necessary torture. He kept his eyes fixed on the floor of the kitchenette, focusing on the monotonous gurgle of the machine.

“I like your cardigan. The color is great on you.”

The voice was gentle, female, and came from beside him. He flinched, nearly dropping his mug.

It was Sarah, a colleague from the design team on the fifth floor. He knew her in that vague, office-way—they’d been on a few cross-departmental projects, exchanged pleasantries by the printer. She was quiet, observant, always dressed in an artistic, effortlessly cool way that he’d never had the vocabulary to describe.

He stared at her, his brain short-circuiting. This wasn't a joke. There was no mockery in her clear, green eyes. Just a genuine, offhand compliment.

“Oh… uh… thanks,” he stammered, his voice cracking slightly. He cleared his throat. “It’s… just something I… picked up.”

She smiled, a small, easy thing. “Well, it’s a good find. It’s nice to see a guy not afraid to wear something soft.” She poured her own coffee and gave him a nod. “Have a good one, Alex.”

And just like that, she was gone.

He stood frozen, the warm mug in his hands. The paranoia, the fear, the shame—it all receded, washed away by a single, kind sentence. It wasn't just the words; it was the way she said them. She hadn't seen a man in women’s clothes. She’d seen him. She’d seen his effort, his tiny step towards authenticity, and she had approved.

He walked back to his desk, his posture graceful. His shoulders were no longer hunched. He felt a strange, new sensation blooming in his chest. It was warm. It was light.

It was hope.

For the rest of the day, the occasional odd look didn't sting anymore. They were just background noise. He replayed Sarah’s comment in his mind, a secret mantra. "It’s nice to see a guy not afraid to wear something girlish."

He wasn't a freak. He wasn't a joke. He was just a person, wearing a cardigan, and someone had noticed. It was the first time a part of his hidden world had been met not with ridicule or confusion, but with simple, unadulterated acceptance.

It was a glimmer, a single, fragile star in a dark sky. But for Alex, it was enough to light the way forward.

The high from Sarah’s compliment carried him through the rest of the day and into the next morning. He felt a new, fragile confidence. The world hadn’t ended. Someone had seen a glimmer of his true self and hadn’t recoiled. He even applied a tiny bit more concealer than usual, enough to truly even out his skin tone, and chose a slightly more fitted, androgynous sweater.

He was starting to believe he could navigate this tightrope.

The email from his boss, Bill, came at 10:17 AM. "Alex, my office. Now. Bring the Q3 analytics."

A standard request. But a cold knot tightened in his stomach nonetheless. Bill’s office was a shrine to a bygone era—wood paneling, a framed photo of a marlin he’d supposedly caught, and the faint, lingering scent of cigar smoke that clung to his suits. Bill was "old school," a term he used with pride, which was corporate code for a particular brand of unvarnished, often brutal, masculinity.

Alex gathered the printouts and walked the long corridor to the corner office, his heart beginning to drum a nervous rhythm. He knocked.

“Enter!”

He pushed the door open and froze. Bill wasn’t alone. Seated in the two leather chairs opposite his desk were Mark and Ben, two of the most notoriously loud-mouthed guys from the sales team. They were Bill’s kind of guys—back-slapping, whiskey-drinking, and relentlessly competitive.

“Rossi! There you are,” Bill boomed, not looking up from his computer. “Close the door.”

Alex did, the click of the latch sounding like a gunshot. He became hyper-aware of the cashmere blend of his sweater, the way his jeans clung to his calves, the subtle sheen of the product on his skin under the harsh office lights.

He took the one remaining seat, feeling three pairs of eyes on him. The air was thick with a predatory stillness.

Bill finally looked up, his gaze, sharp and assessing, swept over Alex. His bushy eyebrows twitched into a slight frown. “You got a hot date after work, Rossi?”

Mark and Ben snickered.

Alex forced a smile. “Just trying to look presentable, Bill.”

“Presentable,” Bill repeated, the word dripping with skepticism. He leaned back in his chair, lacing his fingers over his ample stomach. “You know, I couldn’t help but notice something the other day. And the boys here agreed.”

Ben grinned, a wolfish flash of teeth. “Yeah, man. We were talking. Did you lose your razor? Your face looks… ladylike.”

The floor seemed to drop away. Alex’s skin prickled with a sudden, intense heat. He could feel the blood rushing to his cheeks, a betrayal that would be visible even through the tinted moisturizer.

“Just trying a new skincare routine,” Alex said, his voice tighter than he intended.

“Skincare routine?” Mark chimed in, his tone mockingly incredulous. “What is that, Rossi? You gonna start doing yoga with the girls at lunch, too?”

The laughter was louder now, less restrained. It wasn't friendly. It was the sound of a pack identifying and isolating its weakest member.

Bill’s eyes narrowed, zeroing in on Alex’s face with an unnerving intensity. “Skincare. Right. Let me ask you something, son. What’s that on your face? Is that… foundation?”

The word hung in the air, ugly and final. Foundation. It was the word he’d used in his own head, the clinical term. But in Bill’s mouth, it was a slur. It was the key that unlocked the door to every insecurity he’d ever had.

The three men stared at him, their smiles wide and cruel, waiting for an answer. The silence stretched, punctuated only by the hum of the computer and the thunder of his own heart in his ears. He was completely, utterly exposed. The subtle armor he’d so carefully constructed had been seen through in an instant, and was now being publicly dismantled.

He opened his mouth, but no sound came out. His throat had sealed shut. He just sat there, pinned by their gazes, the heat of his shame so intense he felt dizzy with it.

Bill finally broke the silence with a dismissive wave of his hand. “Ah, lighten up, Rossi. We’re just giving you a hard time. It’s what guys do.” He turned to the papers on his desk, the conversation clearly over. “Now, about these Q3 numbers…”

Alex didn’t hear a single word that was said for the next twenty minutes. He sat perfectly still, a statue of humiliation. The sweater that had felt like a comfort now felt like a neon sign blinking "FRAUD." The makeup on his face felt like a layer of mud he needed to scrape off.

When he was finally dismissed, he walked out of the office on legs that felt like rubber. He didn’t look at anyone. He went straight to the men’s room, locked himself in a stall, and leaned his forehead against the cool metal of the door.

The memory of Sarah’s kind words was ashes. The glimmer of hope was extinguished, crushed under the weight of their mocking laughter. They hadn’t just mocked his clothes or his makeup; they had mocked the very core of what he was exploring, tarnishing it with their contempt.

He had tried to let a little light in, and they had made sure he understood the consequences. He was back in the dark, and this time, the silence was filled with the echo of their laughter.