SamuKata
Michelle Lam
Michelle Lam

patreon


Dr. Stone - Episode 17

Comments

Honestly, I think the author was just made to throw that in so people don't feel weirded out if Senku were to romance one of the Ishigami descendants. Biologically speaking, the descendants are so far removed that it doesn't really matter even if Senku was actually his biological son, but maybe the editors felt they needed to add another degree of separation. My headcanon now for why they look so alike is that Byakuya died his hair and styled it to look similar to Senku's just cause he wanted to avoid anyone thinking Senku was adopted. People (especially kids) can be mean and he wanted to spare Senku any such interactions with idiots. Of course, we know that Senju wouldn't give a fuck (lol), but Byakuya wouldn't have known that when Senku was just a toddler. This falls apart when you think about the fact that Byakuya would've had to continue dying his hair somehow after they landed back on Earth, but I can ignore that part of my brain lol.

Marco St

I know someone else commented this when it was first posted but I noticed the desync at 13:13 still hasn’t been fixed just as a heads up

Gavin Daniels

I've seen other translations that say they're not "direct" blood relations so maybe they are related but he's not his dad (he's like an uncle or something that took him in maybe)? Or this might be a case of even weird shared anime traits not meaning characters are related because anime design is like that sometimes.

Christine Copeland aka Christine's Culinary Quest

The epic of Gilgamesh is a really good book. It's pretty short, but it's influenced fantasy a lot. The idea of a hero character and more importantly "the hero's journey," comes from that story.

Lukas Moser

@Cap That’s certainly possible, but if I were to put money on it, I would bet heavily that the primary reason is to appease potential shippers. The large majority of readers and watchers are going to be children who likely will not look past the fact that the villagers are “related” to Senku. Kohaku’s reaction probably mirrored the reaction of a lot of younger fans. It’s like the author (or more likely the editor) was saying “Here’s the scientific reason why the villagers aren’t related to Senku—them being separated by so much time—and for all the younger fans, they’re DEFINITELY not related because Senku’s adopted anyway.”

Michael H

I knew I couldn't be the only one who kept thinking the music sounds just like Fairy Tail every time the episode title would pop up lol

Kayso

Exactly I said this last episode I love how you can hear all their accents in the dub

Kayso

I'm not the biggest fan of like musical segments but I like it in Dr Stone. Lilian singing kinda reminds me of Disney lol. This episode was really emotional, RIP to them. Then seeing Senku crying at the end of the episode really got to me. Yeah Michelle this is the first time it's been revealed that Senku and Byakuya aren't blood related

Kayso

I would think him saying that 4k years apart meaning there's little to no actual relation is to appease shippers. Him being adopted is simply an emotional aspect meant to highlight him and his fathers bond.

Cap

@Cap I just can’t think of a reason why they would add the adoption aspect. Seems so random to me. And when Kohaku shuddered that they were related to Senku, he reassured them again that he was adopted. It just struck me as a very bizarre attempt to not weird out the shippers.

Michael H

Unless you've seen Senku show any romantic interest in someone, I don't get why you'd think it's about incest

Cap

I don't think so. Senku says in this episode that even if they were blood relatives that him and the current village would be so distant that he'd hardly even be connected to them

Cap

On the one hand, if Senku ends up with someone, yeah, it'll probably be Kohaku. On the other hand, I can't picture him with someone. Science is his true love.

Merfhew

I honestly preferred the dub version of this episode wholefully. Being able to hear the accents and how they each spoke made the conversations feel more real once they got stranded.

IAmRolfie

9:30 This guy isn’t indigenous, he’s someone who was lost at Sea presumably. Which means everyone, everywhere must have been petrified if even the people in the middle of nowhere werr.

IAmRolfie

4:45 If you guys enjoy this lil music cut from the intro you guys would love love LOVE fairy tail, its music sounds exactly like this, and is all very upbeat and fantasy like.

IAmRolfie

Guys, why are you overthinking this? 😂 Senku isn't blood related to Byakuya. In this episode, we learn that he's adopted. It's not a bad translation 😂 And I think, in the end, it doesn't matter whether Senku and Byakuya are related or not. They are and will always be father and son ❤❤

RorotheShadow

I always just assumed that the Author made Senku & his dad not be blood relatives so that viewers don't call it "incest" when Senku & Kohaku become a thing (this isn't a spoiler since I haven't even finished season 2 btw)

Karaka

Senku is adopted

Wsgyan

to Ron : there is actually a movie about an astonaut that's stuck on mars after accidently being left behind by his crew, the movie is called the martian. t's a very good movie worth checking out.

Kevin Depoppe

Senku is adopted lol

지원

Not a bad transition. What you reading is the correct form in what they are trying to tell you

Lemmiwnks

People really didnt give it a chance because of a few 3d animations. Its awesome though

Matej Božič

Unless it becomes a plot point later on that I’m not aware of, Senku being randomly adopted despite looking so much like his dad feels like a really weird attempt to avoid incest between Senku and the village…despite the fact that they are hundreds of generations apart…and that the village spawned from six people…

Michael H

The best hunting show is Golden Kamuy. Literally everything is prey in that show.

ted pasek

I never gave dr stone a chance but then when I started watching it with you guys from episode 1 I can say this anime is so good so far👏🏽

Splahes

Senku knows he's going to reverse the petrification and save everyone but now he knows that the "everyone" does not include his dad. 😢

chaosdreamer

I wasn’t expecting to cry my eyes out today lol I forgot how emotional this episode was to me.

LeNiarfe

Thanks to you guys I resumed my watch for this show and now its in my top 5. This show is so good.

Funnyguyfun7 .

As soon as Ron started saying he would be a hunter in the intro my first thought was, "Okay, so you would be starving to death." lol

Boggie

time does run differently in space, but not by that much if they're so close to earth, you can actually ignore it. This is not Interstella where they went through a wormhole.

Tuấn Hồ

They never show the first couple again, so it’s assumed that they never made it back😕 (And those two were already married at the time we met them, wasn’t sure if you caught that)

envy

its cool but always felt random and weird that the author chose to make em look exactly the same if thats the case

Arz.09

some of the characters' hair colors are just to make the characters stand out, not their actual colors

Mouson

You read that right. Nothing wrong with the translations. Senku is adopted by Byakuya. They are not blood related. That last tombstone was Byakuya's tombstone but it is probably made by the next generation children who wasn't able to make one exactly like the other 3 tombstones.

Phyllis

Oop, audio/visual syncing is off, Editor-in-chief! Right at 13:12. And nope! It's not a mistranslation. Byakuya and Senku are not blood related (I know, they look alike). You didn't forget and it hasn't been mentioned. When it came up in the manga, everyone said what you said....so if THAT happened, it wouldn't be weird to readers/fans, lol. Though Senku did mention that he and the villagers being born 3700+ years apart makes them practically not related.

botanbutton

IT IS 😭😭😭😭

Sudz _son

I think I have something in my eyes

Chris Garcia

i honestly feel like ron is so similar to taiju lol even his answer at the start wanting to keep everyone fed and helping with whatever the most vital task is 😭 he's even the same in his way of being comedic relief lmaooo

Bambi

Senku is adopted, he’s not Byakuya’s son by blood

victoria t

Time on the ISS does go slower but by very little, like a fraction of a second. For time to be noticeably different than on earth you gotta be VERY far away.

Sudz _son

nahh they really arent blood related but they dont care they still see each other as father and son❤️

Blessed

Devante Vickers

Peak

지원


More Creators