Alternative sword sounds. Opinions?

Or, more specifically, have a different type of sound for different types of swords.

Recluse

Both, both are good.

Recluse

So far it is just different pitch. I could make more sound variations later too.

UnrealCrash

I think that every sword should have it's distinct sound when lunging and echoes of it while moving, both sound great in my opinion.

Mokaal

I like both. There should probably be different sounds for certain swords.

AnarchE

Both are pretty good, in my opinion. The second one is way cooler, though, and really fitting for some androids and stuff, I think. I think it's pretty awesome!

Vynity

Hmm. I might use same impact sound (from 2nd preset) for both sword sound presets. In some way. I think one of main focuses here should be for it to sound not like anything else. I could experiment more with sound effects later I guess.

UnrealCrash

Definitely could work. More i listened to it the more i lean on the second one. Seems like alot of people agree with that to on here. Maybe make that the default setting and have the other one as an alternative.

Patty

I prefer the second one. Considering that we use high-tech chopper to fight each other in the game, it will be a little strange to hear the sound effect similar to metal impact. Have you considered something similar to the lightsaber sound effects in Star Wars？

wytily

Honestly, no matter what you implement, it's unique to me. From all the features that you've been showcasing so far, I like all of them!

Paddy D.

So far I do see preferences are mixed. I can just include both as part of skin design in Skin Editor.

UnrealCrash

The first one wins by a landslide. Not sure if its possible but maybe setup a poll for people to vote.

Patty

Personally a big fan of the second!! The first feels too sharp imo even though I love pb2

I like the first sword sound

mhan

They sound fantastic! I think the only sound that may need work is the first set of swords when they hit the ground, the sound is somewhat jarring.

tehswordninja

Sounds a lot more powerful but less "sharp", I like it. Personally a bigger fan of the first, prob cause of nostalgia but they're both really good.

dingodang .

The second one sounds better in my opinion. Its realistic like whistling air because you wouldn't be clashing your own swords if u were trying to fight someone. It sounds very believable to what those swords (im assuming plasma) would probably sound like splitting air.

I think they sound a lot better already. I like both versions for the different sword types. For the first one, the last bit of sound from the effect is a very sharp sound, making it sound not so smooth, end abruptly. Keep it up!

SupremeVoid